This is part of a series of posts on ideas for an ansible-like provisioning system, implemented in Transilience.
Musing about Ansible
I like infrastructure as code.
I like to be able to represent an entire system as text files in a git repositories, and to be able to use that to recreate the system, from my Virtual Private Server, to my print server and my stereo, to build machines, to other kind of systems I might end up setting up.
I like that the provisioning work I do on a machine can be self-documenting and replicable at will.
The good
For that I quite like Ansible, in principle: simple (in theory) YAML files describe a system in (reasonably) high-level steps, and it can be run on (almost) any machine that happens to have a simple Python interpreter installed.
I also like many of the modules provided with Ansible: they are convenient, platform-independent implementations of common provisioning steps. They'd be fantastic to have in a library that I could use in normal programs.
The bad
Unfortunately, Ansible is slow. Running the playbook on my VPS takes about 3 whole minutes even if I'm just changing a line in a configuration file.
This means that most of the time, instead of changing that line in the playbook and running it, to then figure out after 3 minutes that it was the wrong line, or I made a spelling mistake in the playbook, I end up logging into the server and editing in place.
That defeats the whole purpose, but that level of latency between iterations is just unacceptable to me.
The ugly
I also think that Ansible has outgrown its original design, and the supposedly declarative, idempotent YAML has become a full declarative scripting language in disguise, whose syntax is extremely awkward and verbose.
If I'm writing declarative descriptions, YAML is great. If I'm writing loops and conditionals, I want to write code, not templated YAML.
I also keep struggling trying to use Ansible to provision chroots and nspawn containers.
A personal experiment: Transilience
There's another thing I like in Ansible: it's written in Python, which is a language I'm comfortable with. Compared to other platforms, it's one that I'm more likely to be able to control beyond being a simple user.
What if I can port Ansible modules into a library of high-level provisioning functions, that I can just run via normal Python scripts?
What if I can find a way to execute those scripts remotely and not just locally?
I've started writing some prototype code, and the biggest problem is, of course, finding a name.
Ansible comes from Ursula K. Le Guin's Hainish Cycle novels, where it is a device that allows its users to communicate near-instantaneously over interstellar distances. Traveling, however, is still constrained by the speed of light.
Later in the same universe, the novels A Fisherman of the Inland Sea and The Shobies' Story, talk about experiments with instantaneous interstellar travel, as a science Ursula Le Guin called transilience:
Transilience: n. A leap across or from one thing to another [1913 Webster]
Transilience. I like everything about this name.
Now that the hardest problem is solved, the rest is just a simple matter of implementation details.